New to Detroit? Come Visit the Urban Consulate


If you're new to a city, you may wonder where to visit first to get all of the details on where to go, what to eat and who or where to visit. In Detroit, a great first stop is the new Urban Consulate, where weary travelers, newbies and longtime Detroiters are welcome to sit, learn and talk to one another.

Claire Nelson is one of the founders of the Urban Consulate, and she helps to organize the Detroit branch. A winner of the Knight Cities Challenge, Nelson and friends are piloting parlors in three great American cities: Detroit, Philadelphia & New Orleans. Here is a question-and-answer session with Nelson about the new Detroit spot, which is located at 4470 Second Avenue in the city's Midtown area.

Q: What kind of people do you think will use the Consulate: Those who are curious about city life/needs? Are newbies welcome?
A: Absolutely! I was new in Detroit once too, so I have a soft spot for newcomers. I remember how much I didn't understand when I first came to Detroit! It's kind of embarrassing, actually. I owe a lot to patient and merciful teachers. "Be not inhospitable to strangers, lest they be angels in disguise." (Yeats gets credit for that, but I think it appeared in the Bible first!) And listen, cities everywhere (not just Detroit) are feeling the tension between old and new. It's part of why we started the Consulate. It's not really about whether you've been in a city a day or a lifetime, the question is: Are you open to learning? Are you willing to have your mind changed? To me, that's what being "urban" is all about. It's a curiosity and wonder, and a willingness to dive into the complexity that makes cities interesting.

Q: Why did you feel Detroit needed such a space?
A: Well, we all know Detroit is a "curiosity" to many. And not always in a good way. The interest can feel voyeuristic or opportunistic sometimes, yes? So we wanted to create a place for deeper conversations between people across cities and neighborhoods. And we wanted to learn from other places, too.We're intentionally old-school -- old building, intimate gatherings, analog dialogue -- ala the salons and parlors of yesteryear. We all can stand to slow down and share space and listen and ask questions and lead. The Green Garage has already done a lovely job establishing this vibe next door, so we're following their lead.

Q: Why did you create this original programming? How might it change over time?
A: There are so many meaty questions to chew on: What should be protected and preserved, and what is open for rethinking and redesign? What are ways we can develop cities more equitably? These are challenging questions, and we're suspicious of easy answers. We hope the Consulate will be a place for really smart conversations ~ and not just about the shiniest new ideas, but the fundamental ones we sometimes forget. We're experimenting with lots of different formats to see what people enjoy. To be honest, I'm tired of panel discussions where people are talking AT an audience, so we'd like our gatherings to be more conversational and convivial -- a true exchange. So far we've hosted teas, dinners, parlor talks, book clubs, walking tours, co-working hours -- and we're open to other ideas. I'm sure we'll mix it up over time!

Q: With the Consulate, how could people turn talk into action? What are your goals for 1-5 years down the road?
A: Really good question. So here's the thing: Some people are really uncomfortable with just talking, right? They roll their eyes at conversation without action, it feels unproductive. I used to be one of these people -- l hated leaving a room without concrete steps and a plan for what's next. And in Detroit, a lot of challenges feel very urgent, they require immediate attention. But you know what? The pressure to produce has created some of the worst disasters of our time. For real. Quick fixes, fast-growth, not always the best results. And personally, I think my best learning has happened when I stopped long enough to really listen, or encountered a new idea I wasn't seeking -- and maybe it didn't sink in right away, but revealed itself over time. So it's okay to have a conversation today, and let it wash over you for a while. If something inspires or surprises you, it will show up in your work. Trust.

Q: What else do you want people to know that I haven't asked?
A: We have a poster hanging in our foyer that says "Never Stop Learning." It seems simple and obvious enough, but I look out at the world and I see a lot of people who think they've got it all figured out.
The number one principle in Bruce Mau's "Incomplete Manifesto for Growth" is my favorite: "Allow events to change you." The prerequisites for growth, Mau says, are the openness to experience events and the willingness to be changed by them. This is HUGELY important in cities -- we see it time and time again. Urban designers and planners and investors and developers will be on some course, determined that their ideas and solutions are making places better. And then some time passes and WAIT...hold up...we have a new set of problems. We saw it with urban renewal, and suburban sprawl, and we're seeing it now with gentrification. And if you keep on keeping on, pushing that same agenda you were a decade ago, without stopping to listen to a protest, or a poem, you are no longer a problem-solver, you are the problem. But if we keep on seeking out different perspectives, and let them influence our thinking -- we're gonna be alright.

Karen Dybis is a longtime Metro Detroit freelance writer. She is an author of two Detroit history books, reporter for a variety of area blogs, newspapers and magazines.